United States: Super Bowl ad hypocrisy

February 14, 2010
Issue 

In our 5000-channel, Tweeting, shouting culture of constant distraction, there are precious few annual events that unite the US national gaze. In fact, there is really only one: the Super Bowl.

Over the last two decades, ratings for everything from the World Series to the Olympics have stumbled — but the NFL championship gets stronger with age. Super Bowl Sunday is becoming a defacto national holiday.

The cultural power of the big game cannot be overstated, and that's exactly why CBS's decision to air an anti-abortion ad funded by Focus on the Family was so terribly wrongheaded.

The ad features Florida quarterback and staunch evangelical Christian Tim Tebow alongside his mother, Pam, speaking out against abortion. Pam tells the world how she ignored a doctor's advice while on a missionary trip in the Philippines and decided to have her fifth child — Tim.

She was suffering from a serious tropical illness, the story goes, and doctors thought that having the child would kill her. But she "chose life" for her child and the result is an all-American quarterback.

There is something sketchy about this story — abortion is illegal in the Philippines. It seems highly unlikely the procedure would be recommended to an evangelical missionary.

But this isn't about truth in advertising. It's about Tim Tebow continuing his self-proclaimed goal to use football as a "missionary".

After a college career wearing eyeblack with Bible verses stenciled in, it's the next step in raising his platform as the most outspoken evangelical this side of Sarah Palin.

To be clear, we should absolutely support Tebow's right to state his political beliefs loudly and proudly and we should soundly reject the concept that jocks should just "shut up and play".

But there are other things we should soundly reject as well. We should reject the utter hypocrisy on display by CBS in airing this ad. The network has long stated that it has Super Bowl rules against "advocacy ads".

In 2004, the network rejected a Super Bowl ad from the United Church of Christ in which a church is shown opening its doors to a gay couple. The network has also refused ads from PETA, MoveOn.org and many others.

This year, it even rejected a humorous commercial from a gay dating site called Mancrunch.com.

And yet, the network takes money from Focus on the Family — which, according to People for the American Way, is "anti-choice, anti-gay and against sex education curricula that are not strictly abstinence-only".

The group's guru is the infamous James Dobson, a frightening fellow, who chose the second night of Passover last year to say: "The biggest Holocaust in world history came out of the Supreme Court", with the ground-breaking 1973 pro-choiceRoe v. Wade ruling.

Dobson's other pet project, the Family Research Council, has connections to white supremacist organisations like the Council of Conservative Citizens. In 1996, Family Research Council president Tony Perkins paid former Ku Klux Klan grand wizard David Duke US$82,000 for his mailing list.

The idea that this organisation is acceptable to CBS, while MoveOn or PETA or the United Church of Christ are too radical, actually adds up to a right-wing assault on free speech.

We could also point out the irony that this year, like all others, ads for the US armed forces will be omnipresent, but that's not considered advocacy either. I doubt there would be equal time for Iraq Veterans Against the War, even if it could pony up the millions.

The other thing we need to reject is the sports media's love affair with Tim Tebow's "courage" in being a part of this ad.

People like CBS's Jim Nantz and Sports Illustrated's Peter King are like tweens at a Justin Bieber concert when it comes to Tebow. King recently wrote: "What I heard from Tebow was the voice of a kid with convictions, who doesn't shrink from what he believes — even if it might hurt his draft prospects."

Wrong: The fact that Tebow has massive accuracy problems and can't take a snap from center without fumbling is what is going to hurt his draft prospects.

Moreover, it rankles that Tebow is being extolled for his courage while athletes who have spoken out against militarism (Carlos Delgado and, most famously, Muhammad Ali) or racism (Josh Howard) are called crazy and tiresome.

Let's hope that the next time an athlete speaks out — even if it's in the service of a left-wing cause — the media remember their praise of Tebow and cut him or her some slack.

And let's hope that the next time CBS gets an ad query from a group with an agenda diametrically opposed to Focus on the Family's, the network gives it equal time.

Hosting the Super Bowl, this great unifying event, ought to be considered a privilege. And CBS has already failed the test.

[Abridged from www.edgeofsports.com.]

You need Green Left, and we need you!

Green Left is funded by contributions from readers and supporters. Help us reach our funding target.

Make a One-off Donation or choose from one of our Monthly Donation options.

Become a supporter to get the digital edition for $5 per month or the print edition for $10 per month. One-time payment options are available.

You can also call 1800 634 206 to make a donation or to become a supporter. Thank you.