A debate is raging in British trade unions about what sort of relationship they should have with the Labour Party. Key figures took up the debate at a September 15 fringe meeting held during the annual conference of the Trades Union Congress (Britain's peak union body), held in Brighton on September 13-17. Reprinted below from the British Socialist Worker weekly are edited versions of the speeches by Transport and General Workers Union general secretary Tony Woodley and Public and Commercial Services (PCS) union general secretary Mark Serwotka.
Tony Woodley: It's an important time to realise that everyone is working as hard as possible to win a change of direction in the Labour Party. For the first time we have seen every union affiliated to Labour stick together.
We haven't made enough or sufficient progress.
There were real gains that can go some way to reinvigorating party members. Let's not forget the party and the unions are like the church running out of parishioners. But we cannot lose sight of one crucial thing — we have to be in power to make a difference.
When you look at things like the sacking of 100,000 civil servants it's unbelievable. Other policies are just unbelievable. But it's nothing compared with the disaster of the Tories getting back.
A lot of the demoralisation among party members is associated with this illegal, immoral war that this lunatic [Prime Minister Tony Blair] has led us into. But there is also the whole issue of rights at work. We are going to see our government in the European courts over that issue.
We need changes to the law to allow my Jaguar workers to fight back. Ford is announcing the closure of the Coventry plant with not one word of consultation with any union in this country.
But this is not a time to be dispirited. It's a time to be vibrant about what we have started to achieve in the Labour Party.
Mark Serwotka: My starting point is that there is more that unites us than divides us. That is true for those pursuing the campaign to reclaim the Labour Party and those of us who are not. We need to unite around all the issues and fights we face.
We can all here agree on what is wrong with this Labour government. But it is worth reminding ourselves of two of the worst things. The anti-union laws remain fundamentally in place, and this government has taken us to war seven times since 1997.
Of course, presented with a choice between a Labour government and a Tory government, we do not want the Tories. But if you are, for example, a PCS member at the moment you are asking fundamental questions.
The Tories want to axe 200,000 jobs. Labour is cutting 104,500 jobs. It does not feel like there is much of a difference if you are about to be sacked.
The question is whether we always want to be restricted to that choice. That's what I ask when I look at my kids, aged nine and seven. And here there is a debate.
Yesterday, the TUC unanimously backed the fight to defend civil service jobs. But at the general council dinner last night, Labour Party chairman Ian McCartney did not even mention the job cuts yet, with some exceptions, he received a standing ovation.
I would have no problem supporting John McDonnell and the other left wing MPs who have spoken out. But if I lived in east London and George Galloway of Respect was standing, I do not see why people should vote for Labour's Oona King.
We will all back left MPs standing, but I hope you will accept that where credible alternatives to New Labour candidates are emerging they should get support. Not accepting that will lead to the politics of sectarianism and lead us down blind alleys.
People used to say in Scotland there could never be an alternative to Labour. But after the success of the Scottish Socialist Party it is inconceivable to go to Glasgow and say, "Support Labour against Tommy Sheridan".
If we don't manage to take the debate forward we face the danger of being in the same position in five years' time with the same limited choice.
From Green Left Weekly, September 29, 2004.
Visit the Green Left Weekly home page.